Everyone’s favorite casino-worker-turned-amateur-sleuth is back on the case in Poker Face season 2. Actually, make that several cases as Charlie Cale (Natasha Lyonne) has to solve mysteries involving murderous quintuplets (all played by Wicked actress Cynthia Erivo), a missing funeral owner’s wife and a female mob boss who needs help finding a mole within her gang.
Much of what made season 1 so entertaining is present in season 2, including a still-terrific Lyonne as the sarcastic gumshoe, a cavalcade of unusual guest stars (John Mulaney, Haley Joel Osment and Katie Holmes all show up at some point), and a case-of-the-week plot structure that feels both retro and different from other mystery shows. Poker Face season 2 has 10 episodes; the first three are now streaming.